There were a lot of comments to that post though saying how much commenters hated the bitchy reviews of Burda that bloggers write and now I feel kind of guilty. I don't think I'm the bitchiest reviewer on the internet, but I do laugh at Burda's styling, and I laugh A LOT at some of their wackier designs, and their Giant Rectangles. However, I also know I can be proven wrong with Burda: sometimes I look at a pattern and just go "Crazypants!" and move on, but then I'll see it made up and think, no, wow, that's actually really great on her. I kind of want to be proved wrong on this month's Ghengis-Khan-as-diner-waitress dress, for example, though I'm reserving judgement on whether that is even really possible. I also cringe when I see reviewers just outright call a pattern hooker-wear, or critique the model's body. There's a line I try not to cross between amused aesthetic critique, which I don't represent as anything other than my actually very shallow and unfashionable opinion, and sort of contemptuous commentary that would make me angry if I read it.
I don't know. I like writing my Burda reviews and I know there are people reading this blog, but with all due respect, I'm really not writing this blog for an audience. I just needed somewhere to put all the non-stop sewing thoughts and commentary that run through my head, and I have literally nowhere else. I am happy to know that there are people reading and sometimes commenting, but I wouldn't stop writing even if you all vanished overnight. The truth is, I'm not ever going to be a a big name blogger. I can't really imagine how I'd ever monetize this blog. I feel bad enough linking my Etsy shop (currently down, as my inventory is, like everything else fun in my life, all in a box in Cumbria), to be honest. Does it matter if someone, or even several someones, I don't know thinks I'm kind of a bitch for suggesting that one dress pattern looked like it had a deconstructed kangaroo pouch buttoned to the front?
So there's that. On the other side of the coin, I was thinking last night about clothes I would make for an imaginary life in which I was not myself excessively self-conscious about my body and my clothes. This was brought on by the fact that I was looking at some of the things I've pinned to my Outfits I Like board on Pinterest and observed to myself that quite often these are of outfits that are just slightly different than the norm. Not like, way out there, crazy artist style, but just a bit different. I keep hoping I will suddenly grow into the sang-froid that many women seem to acquire with age, where they just go, no, I WILL wear my [insert oddball garment here] and screw you if you think I look weird. However, I'm creeping up on 40 and I've not achieved it yet. Alas. Part of the problem with sewing though it's that it's hard to just try something out. Like, if I wanted to try a style of dress, I could notionally just go try on loads of dresses somewhere and see what looked good (in practice, I don't do this because I have so many sizing problems with dresses and I hate shop changing rooms with their lighting tricks and their mirror games). With oddball garments, you have to make them to try them because you CAN'T buy them anywhere.
On a similar theme though, I have this great vintage pattern for a really long sort of waistcoat thing:
I go back and forth between OMG CUTEST and BUT WHEN WOULD I WEAR IT. Alas, probably doomed to never be made up.
I like critical reviews of anything, especially if they are amusing. Those who don't like the negative reviews of pattern they like need to get over themselves. There is nothing in the world that everyone likes. I have read plenty of negative reviews of patterns I like, but as I usually put my big girl panties on every morning I can deal with it.
ReplyDeleteYeah, I don't know that I can fully understand some of the complaints about it. Like, I genuinely don't like reading when people are really negatively about the model's body as if it's her BODY that is the problem rather than crappy styling or Burda just not matching their sewn sample and the model's figure together. If someone does that frequently, I'll take their blog off my reader to avoid being annoyed.
DeleteHowever, if it's just someone going "UGLY!" and I thought it was awesome, well, for one thing, if we all had the same taste, what the hell would be the whole point of fashion. And second, frankly, if I can't deal with someone being critical about one little thing I like, I should probably GTFO the internet.
I strongly believe that a person's blog is there for them to put on what they want and trust that you will get the readers that enjoy your content. There is something for everyone out there. I often find blogs that I am not attracted to for some reason so I don't sign up. When I do subscribe to a blog and the writer says something I disagree with - I just think that it is their opinion on their blog.
ReplyDeleteGo ahead and write your honest reviews.
Personally I don't buy Burda - the tracing off does scare me. And then I see a great item I really want and can't find in enveloped patterns - like skirt L from You Sew Girl just did.
I like Burda because despite the amount I laugh at it, there are quite a lot of things in it that I would wear. And the tracing doesn't bother me all that much. I tend to put something mindless on the TV and trace a couple of different patterns at once.
DeleteWrite what you want. Why would you care what other people think if you are writing it for yourself?
ReplyDeleteI like the outfit you've linked to. It's very stylish.
I mostly don't care, but I was kind of taken aback how angry some of them seemed over it.
Delete